So, I'm starting to think this whole "sell your jewellery" thing is a big fat crock.

I don't get why the fad is still going. Selling gold to be melted down is a HUGE rip off, in my opinion, as will be evidence by this little post I'm about to share about my recent experience trying to sell to Toronto's Omni Jewelcrafters at Bathurst & Glencairn.
Here's how it went:

I went to Omni hoping to sell 3 things. These things are as follows:

1) A 14k gold circle pendant (with chain) featuring a ring of small diamonds. (Original price: about $500)
2) A pair of diamond earrings (studs). Smallish, by v. high quality diamonds, set in white gold. (Original price: $750)
3) One 18k gold earring set with six small diamonds (like the ones in the circle pendant) that didn't have a mate. It was real, but I don't know how much it cost, because I found it in Heathrow airport six years ago.

I wasn't expecting that much, but considering that I had original receipts and/or appraisal documents for each item, I figured I might get a nice little chunk of change. Maybe... $200? $250?

Not even close. Omni offered me $110. For all three items combined.

Now, this is jewellery I don't want. It's stuff I don't wear. Besides the found earring, it was all given to me by an ex and is infected with bad juju. I WANTED to sell it, but I just couldn't bring myself to settle for such a crappy pay out.

I had receipts! I had appraisals! But in the world of jewellery hocking, such things mean nothing, I've learned.

Perhaps I should have known. I mean, consider the kinds of ads these outfits run.
_I definitely should have known.

I'd also like to add that the clerk at Omni was a bit smarmy and condescending, which didn't make me want to make a deal. Regarding the pendant necklace, he said "I know it's pretty and it sparkles, but it's not really worth anything." And "these diamonds are sOooo small ... it would cost me as much as they're worth to remove them from the setting."

Um. Yeah right, I thought. You could take apart this setting in five minutes, buster. You're not fooling anyone.

The whole experience was lame. I parted with the one earring and was paid $20 for it. (Six little diamonds, plus the thick gold setting and all I got was $20. But hey... he was doing me a favour, right? The diamonds were soooo small.) I let the earring go because I'd found it. Didn't seem fair to profit too much from someone else's loss. But I took the rest of my pieces home.

After having this experience, I can't understand why people sell jewellery this way at all. You've got to be desperate.

Maybe I'll do some sort of bad juju cleansing and start wearing this stuff again. Maybe I'll regift it. Who knows?

Omni Jewel & Java Café
2793 Bathurst St.
Toronto, ON M6B 3A4
(416) 783-2091

P.S. Also, there's a built in café/restaurant at the Omni location I visited. Because it makes total sense to combine food service and fine jewellery sales? Totally weird.
 


Comments

01/13/2012 12:01

A friend recently sold gold jewelry but did a LOT of comparison shopping between those Cash For Gold places, jewelry stores, and pawn shops. Surprisingly, a local pawn shop paid her the most money, but only after she told him she was going to take it back to another pawn shop who offered more. He immediately doubled his offer. It turned out to be the best offer of about a dozen.

You can get a decent offer, but you have to be prepared to do a lot of legwork to get multiple offers from a variety of places in your area, which may or may not be worth it, depending on how badly you want to sell.

Reply
Megan Rhiannon
01/13/2012 20:56

J's mom sold some gold jewelry through that program where you send it in the mail and they send you a quote then a cheque if you agree to the quote. Very good return. For perfectly good jewelry with diamonds I would pawn it. Try a few places, you never know! Or give it all too me!!! Muhahahahaha!!!! 'I like gold!!!!!!!!'

Reply
01/16/2012 17:20

yeah i tried one of these deals too with a pair of diamond earrings from an ex - he very professionally and politely offered me $7. Somehow I managed to decline and wait until i left the office before laughing.

Reply
03/18/2012 22:07

I sold some jewelry awhile ago, and didn't get as much as I had hoped, but I suspected as much. None of it was as valuable as what you sold. But I was kind of glad to be rid of it, so the money was fine.

If you want to be rid of the jewelry, but don't want the insult of the money, can you donate it to a local charity or something, which would give some money to a good cause, and maybe you'd get a write off? Here in the U.S., you don't have to have documentation for any donation less than $250. So I can donate a necklace that cost me $300, but I know they're going to sell for $20, and get to write it off for $250. Just a thought. Or, re-gift it, if you can think of someone who might really love it. The necklace is beautiful. Would it be bad juju to save it for your niece when she's 18 or so?

Reply
03/18/2012 22:10

btw, regarding bad juju...my engagement ring has a diamond from my husband's parents' marriage, which was very unhappy and ended in a painful divorce. It hasn't hurt my marriage at all, we're very happy. There are no jewelry curses. The only curse is if it brings you unhappiness, or your husband unhappiness, to see them.

Reply



Leave a Reply